Friday, August 19, 2011

Old Dominion Football Preview - The Trenches

We have taken the time to preview all eleven of ODU football's 2011 opponents, the summary of which you can find here.  It's now time to look at the Monarchs themselves, position-by-position.  We're going to do this a little differently than some might find logical but we've got to find different angles to look at things, right?  It all will make sense by the time the Monarchs kick off September 3 against Campbell University.  After examining the different positions, we'll do a series of posts assessing how ODU's talent stacks up against the best of the CAA.

We'll begin with the two units that will have the biggest impact on Old Dominion's success in 2011 - the offensive and defensive lines.  Thomas DeMarco won't live up to his preseason CFPA Award Watch List expectations if the line can't block for him, nor will the linebackers show improvement if the defensive line cannot hold their own in the CAA.

OFFENSIVE LINE

2010 was a challenging year for the Monarchs' o-line before it even started.  One freshman who was expected to contribute immediately transferred to a D-II school to be closer to home.  Ryan Jensen, who started all eleven games in 2009 at right tackle, missed all of 2010 due to an injury.  Tight end Kai Blanco temporarily converted to OL just to provide depth at the position.

The linemen remaining were so banged up before the season opener against Jacksonville that the coaching staff enforced two-hand-touch rules the last few practices.  And then the hits kept coming during the season.  Center Jeremy Hensley suffered a season-ending ankle injury in a 50-37 loss to Cal-Poly midway through the season.  Right tackle Brandon Carr finished the season at center while right guard Robbie Duncan moved over to RT.  True freshman Mike Justice played five games along the line; the coaching staff was hoping to redshirt Justice but he was forced into action with the injuries.

Despite the moving parts of the line throughout the season, the offense barely missed a beat.  Left tackle Tobin Cameron and left guard Bryan Morrison played all eleven games.  Carr and Duncan also played the entire season, albeit while rotating positions.  With all the shuffling and missed games, the offensive line still paved the way for a respectible 140 rushing yards per game while giving up only nine sacks.  Considering the step up in the talent of their 2010 opponents compared to the 2009 schedule, the line should be proud of what they accomplished. 

The Monarchs offensive line opened several holes for Thomas DeMarco and Company.

The 2011 season is shaping up to be much smoother than last season, which is a welcomed change considering the talent of the CAA.  Cameron, who had started all 22 games at left tackle in Monarch football history, is lost to graduation.  Ryan Jensen was redshirted due to his injury and is now slated to take over for Cameron.  Hensley returns to assume the starting center role again in his senior season.  Carr, Duncan and Morrison all return after playing every game last season. 

The five returning players listed above form a talented, experienced line.  However, the talent doesn't stop there.  Two JUCO transfers arrived in time for spring camp - DJ Morrell and David Born.  Morrell arrives with two seasons of eligibility remaining after playing the prior two years at Dean Junion College.  He picked Old Dominion over established conference mates UMass and Rhode Island.  The 6-8, 340-pound Born played one season at Bakersfield College and has three years of eligibility with ODU.  These two bring proven talent to the line and are pushing for playing time.

Along with Justice, who did not get to redshirt last season, there is a bevy of young offensive linemen in addition to those listed above.  Redshirt sophomore Jack Lowney started five games at right guard last season.  Lowney is joined by Perry Owens (RS sophomore), Wes Moulton (RS freshman) and Ellett McGeorge (RS freshman) to form a young basis for future seasons.

There are two true freshmen joining the line, both "757" recruits - Josh Mann and Conor Mewbourne.  Mann was named to the Virginia High School All-State Team by the AP as a senior, having started all four seasons of high school.  He also seems to be a pretty well-rounded individual.  Mewbourne was named to the All-Beach First District Team his senior season.  Although we'd like to see both players redshirted considering the depth in front of them, Mann is already getting serious looks at guard in training camp. 

Old Dominion quarterbacks were sacked only nine times in 2010.

At this point the only known starters are Jensen (RT) and Hensley (C).  It's reasonable to expect Carr, Duncan and Morrison to get strong consideration to be starters early in the season as they have more experience in the system than others.  If players other than those three are tabbed starters, it will most likely be Justice, Morrell or Born.  But no matter who starts, the unit will be in much better position than last year to handle injuries along the line.

DEFENSIVE LINE

Whereas injuries impacted the lineup of the offensive line last season, they're already starting to affect the defensive line.  Redshirt junior Andrew Turner, who started most of the last two seasons at defensive end, suffered an achilles injury in spring camp.  This is a big blow to a team that was already losing Deron Mayo to graduation.  The DE/LB hybrid player is currently in the Denver Broncos camp. 

We'll blame the Greeks and their mythology for the loss of Turner. 
But before looking at the current DL composition, let's take a look at the 2010 results.  Without a doubt the unit was bolstered by Hofstra transfers Mayo and Ronnie Cameron.  Cameron finished second on the Monarchs with 72 tackles while tying for eighth overall in the FCS with 19 tackles for loss.  Let me repeat that - a DT led all but one teammate in total tackles.  The CAA Football Blog produced a nice article on Cameron during the spring, focusing on his impact on the program to date. 

Beyond Turner, Mayo and Cameron, the line got significant contributions from Edmond McClam, Chad King, Erik Saylor and Chris Burnette.  The DL showed drastic improvement from 2009 (allowing 167 rushing yards per game) to 2010 (132 yards/game) against better competition.  There was also a jump in sacks, going from 22 to 29.  Needless to say, the overall improvement in the defense started up front with the defensive line.

The defensive line held a lead at North Carolina Central University after DeMarco left with an injury.

With the losses of Mayo and Turner, the defensive line is missing two important pieces from the 2010 season.  The team will get to see redshirt freshmen Preston Smith, Jagger Blehm and Dominique Guinn-Bailey in live action for the first time this season.  Guinn-Bailey was named Second Team All-Tidewater as a senior in high school.  Additionally, Dontez Tyler joins the Monarchs as a true freshman after previously committing to the University of Maryland.  Tyler has the skill set to replace Mayo, but we won't know how he develops until he hits the field. 

The 2011 picture is an inverse of what we saw on offense.  We know who the starters should be (barring changes in the next two weeks) - Cameron, King, McClam and Burnette.  That is a starting defensive line I'd put up against anyone in the CAA.  Conversely there is minimal proven depth on the bench behind the starters and Saylor.  There are seven redshirt-or-true freshmen ends and tackles on the roster, none of whom have played a down for the Monarchs.  Redshirt sophomores Alex Johnson and Nate Barnes appeared in eight and nine games, respectively, in minimal roles in the 2010 season. 

Here's wishing health to the starting defensive linemen.  The CAA is a tough league to learn the ropes in the trenches, so giving significant playing time to newbies is not the best recipe for success.  If you're looking for an unexpected hero, keep your eyes on Alex Johnson.

Offenses in the CAA are a bit better than offenses like NCCU.  Is the Monarchs defensive line up to the challenge?

CONCLUSION

There is reason for optimism along both lines for the Monarchs.  Despite the slew of injuries in 2010, the offensive line was more than effective.  Proven depth is now complemented by talented newcomes.  Meanwhiile the defensive line is top-heavy.  The loss of two key players hurts the depth, and that could end up hampering the overall defense this season.  But the young guys will have to prove themselves sooner or later; why not sooner?

Next up we'll take a look at running backs and linebackers. 

Wednesday, August 17, 2011

Old Dominion 2011 Football Opponents

I took a decent amount of time to research each of Old Dominion football's 2011 opponents.  Below is a quick link to each team's specific preview.  There will be previews specific to ODU's offense, defense, special teams and coaching in the next couple days.  I just wanted to take a break tonight.  No matter how much I love football and ODU, even I needed a chance to step away from the keyboard.

Home teams are in CAPS. 

September 3 - CAMPBELL UNIVERSITY

September 10 - at Georgia State University

September 17 - HAMPTON UNIVERSITY

September 24 - at the University of Delaware

October 1 - UNIVERSITY OF MASSACHUSETTS

October 8 - at the University of Rhode Island

October 15 - TOWSON UNIVERSITY

October 22 - at Villanova University

October 29 - JAMES MADISON UNIVERSITY

November 5 - UNIVERSITY OF RICHMOND

November 12 - at The College of William and Mary

Tuesday, August 16, 2011

William and Mary Football Preview

On November 12, Old Dominion University will conclude its first season as members of CAA Football.  Their opponent?  Only The College of William and Mary, one of the best FCS teams heading into the 2011 season.  There are several angles from which to attack this game, and we'll keep it as condensed as possible since the teams already played once, a 21-17 Tribe victory. 

Thomas DeMarco and the Monarchs played the Tribe tough in 2010, losing by only four points.

Football History
The College of William and Mary was founded in 1693 and is the second-oldest institution of higher learning in America.  Its football program began 200 years later in 1893 and has accumulated a record of 548-523-41.  For comparison's sake, Old Dominion University has existed since 1930 and has a two-year record of 17-5, falling more than 500 wins short of the Tribe's total.  Coach Jimmye Laycock has become a fixture of the program; in 31 years of coaching his record with the Tribe is 210-145-2.  The College has had its share of players reach the NFL, with Darren Sharper easily its most accomplished pro football player.  Lastly, W&M plays its home games a Zable Stadium, which seats upwards of 12K fans.


Zable Stadium is home of the Tribe football team.  (Photo credited to Williamsburgcc.com)

2010 Highlights
William and Mary finished the regular season tied with Delaware as Co-CAA conference champions.  Having a record of 8-3 and hosting a playoff game after a bye, the Tribe lost to GSU 31-15.  Despite the unexpectedly quick exit from the FCS playoffs, the Tribe had a decent season.  They attained the #1 ranking in FCS for the first time in its history during the season.  Running back Jonathan Grimes and TE Alex Gottlieb were voted All-CAA First Team (Grimes was named CAA Special Teams POY).  There were also three Tribe players on the All-CAA Second Team. 

Grimes was fourth amongst CAA running backs with almost 900 rushing yards, and led the entire conference with 1,620 all-purpose yards, almost 200 yards more than the next closest player.  Grimes and Chase Hill were among CAA leaders with eight total touchdowns each.  On defense, Marcus Hyde finished tied for second in the conference with 5.5 sacks. 

The team's three regular season losses were at UMass, at UNC (a game where they took the lead into the fourth quarter before injuries ravished them) and at JMU.  This team was not short on talent.  I feel like I've said that about most teams in my previews.  Regardless, the three losses were by a combined 14 points!  Oh so close to perfection.  But 8-3 is pretty impressive considering the rigors of the CAA.

History with Old Dominion
Of all of its opponents, no matter the sport, ODU shares the most history with W&M.  ODU was founded in 1930 as The Norfolk Division of The College of William and Mary.  It was essentially a two-year school for students in the Hampton Roads area to get credits for classes to then attend the Williamsburg campus.  The Norfolk campus became Old Dominion College in 1962 and Old Dominion University in 1969.  More than a decade later, those three years as a student tour guide continue to serve me well.

Without William and Mary, there would be no ODU.
Originally ODU had scheduled William and Mary in its inaugural season.  The Monarchs administration wisened up and backed out of that contest, well aware that the Tribe would be too much for ODU to handle in its first season.  The 2010 game was not cancelled, though, and it was an exciting time for both programs, their fans and the CAA in general.  There was genuine electricity in the air as ODU held a lead through 2/3 of the fourth quarter, only to see the superior team score a touchdown to take a 21-17 lead that would hold until the end. 

There was some debate about how ODU players conducted themselves during the game.  Coach Laycock came out after the game and shared his concerns over that.  Old Dominion coach Bobby Wilder offered a response, saying (nicely) that ODU was his team and that Laycock should worry only about his own team.  In fairness there were multiple personal fouls committed by ODU that should not have happened.  The team had its share of personal foul trouble in its short history prior to the W&M game.  However, after the W&M game, Wilder took corrective action and there were noticably fewer personal fouls going forward.

I share all this background because the two things discussed following the game were (1) the extraordinary atmosphere at the game and (2) the personal foul situation.  The latter will be mentioned every season going forward when the teams play. 


The 2009-2010 men's basketball team received their CAA Championship rings during the W&M/ODU game.  You may recall that ODU beat W&M in the 2010 CAA men's championship.

2011 Outlook
I fully expect William and Mary to win the CAA outright this season and compete for the FCS national title.  The team returns more than half of its starters on both offense and defense.  Offensive lineman James Pagliaro joined Gottlieb and Grimes on the 2011 preseason All-CAA Team on offense.  Marcus Hyde leads three Tribe players on the preseason All-CAA Team on defense.  The team's top two leaders in sacks and three of the four leaders in TFL return.

Through three seasons, Grimes is already the programs's all-time leader in all-purpose yards and is top-ten in rushing yards, rushing attempts and total touchdowns.  I expect him to be awarded the Walter Payton Award.  Coach Laycock will get as much out of this workhorse as he can.

The only question I have for this team is the play of the quarterback.  Michael Paulus, who transferred from UNC, is more than capable of leading this team.  But can he stay healthier in 2011 than he did in 2010?  If he cannot, who will come in to replace him?  The top QB from last year's team was Mike Callahan, but he is lost to graduation in 2011.  Even without a gunslinger at QB, the top priority of the Tribe's signal-caller will be to hand the ball to Jonathan Grimes.

The Tribe prevailed against Old Dominion 2010.  How will the 2011 rematch play out?
Summary
To be frank, if W&M doesn't reach the FCS semi-finals this season then it should be considered a disappointment.  The Tribe have three preseason All-CAA players on both offense and defense, led by All-Everything Jonathan Grimes.  It's difficult to pick against the Tribe against any of its opponents, including the Virginia Cavaliers on September 3, if the team is at full strength.  The only game I'll get to see the Tribe play in person will be their season finale at Richmond, so there'll be a lot of football played between now and then.  The Tribe have more proven talent and depth than most teams in the CAA, and that should be enough to get them to the FCS national title game.

Monday, August 15, 2011

Richmond University Football Preview

So far we've reviewed the first nine opponents of Old Dominion University's 2011 football season.  There is no scheduled bye week until the final week of the regular season.  By the time the Monarchs close out their home schedule against the University of Richmond, they will have played CAA opponents in six consecutive weeks (and opponents in nine straight weeks overall).  It's natural to expect that injuries will have taken their toll on this ODU squad by this point; no matter their record by November 5, they'll be a bit beaten up.

With that said, Richmond is Old Dominion's opponent on its Senior Night.  Players such as team leaders Thomas DeMarco and Ronnie Cameron will be given a proper send-off by an ODU crowd that truly appreciates what they've done for the program.  But I'll preview ODU soon enough; for now, bring on the Ticks!

Football History
The University of Richmond was founded in 1830, the oldest CAA Football institution of higher learning we've previewed to date.  Since starting football in 1881, the Spiders have attained an overall record of 497-609-53.  With so many more years than most opponents ODU will face, they've had a share in at least 13 conference championships.  They've had their share of recent success, making the FCS semifinals in 2007 and winning the FCS national title in 2008.  Richmond had played its home football games at City Stadium through 2009; they had built and moved into Robins Stadium in 2010.

Robins Stadium, the current home of the University of Richmond football team (photo credited to Richmond - The Alumni Magazine).

2010 Highlights
After head coach Mike London departed Richmond to coach at the University of Virginia, expectations were still reasonably high for 2010.  It took about a week for UR to replace London with Latrell Scott, who had served previously as the Spiders' WR coach.  The offense was expected to get a boost with Aaron Corp at quarterback; Corp was transfering in from the University of Southern California after two seasons.  The defense was also returning a significant amount of talent.

City Stadium in Richmond (photo credited to the Richmond Times-Dispatch).  I can't believe a Division I football program played its games at this dilapidated venue prior to 2010.

Unfortunately Corp suffered a knee injury in the Spiders' fifth game of the season against New Hampshire, and his season was done.  Richmond finished 2-2 in the four games Corp started, and 4-3 other games.  The offense finished tied for last in the conference in points scored at 15.5 points/game.  Leading rusher Tyler Kirchoff was tenth in the conference with 547 rushing yards, while All-CAA First Team WR led UR receivers with 38 catches/478 yards receiving.

The defense had its own share of standouts, but collectively it wasn't good enough to overcome a deficient offense.  Three Spiders were named All-CAA First Team - DT Martin Parker, LB Eric McBridge and CB Justin Rogers.  Rogers was drafted in the seventh round by the Buffalo Bills; five bucks says he ends his pro career with more sacks than Aaron Maybin. 


Justin Rogers was a leader on the Spiders 2010 defense.  (Photo credited to TheCollegianUR.com)

When it was all said and done, the Spiders offense simply couldn't score enough points.  Losing a BCS-level talent at QB was too much for a talented defense to overcome.  As such, despite wins over UMass and JMU, the team finished only 6-5.

History with Old Dominion Football
This will be the first meeting on the football field between Richmond and Old Dominion. 

Kent Bazemore had a coming-of-age game against Richmond in 2010.  This image is pretty bad-ass. (Photo credited to Preston Gannaway, The Virginian-Pilot)
2011 Outlook
The defense loses six starters to graduation, including the three First Teamers discussed above.  I've mentioned this in a preview of Hampton University, but it's hard to lose six starters (three of which were all-conference members) and actually improve on defense.  There were no Spiders on the 2011 preseason All-CAA team on defense.

The offense, however, should show a marked improvement over the 2010's results.  Four offensive linemen who started a significant portion of 2010 return; even though leading-rusher Kirchoff is lost to graduation, you should expect the offensive line to open up holes for players like Kendall Gaskins and Jovan Smith.  If Aaron Corp stays healthy in 2011 then he's an automatic upgrade over the collective 2010 unit.  Tre Gray returns as a preseason All-CAA WR.

The difficult schedule may do more harm to Richmond's success than anything they can control.  The Spiders play at JMU, at Delaware, host William and Mary and New Hampshire.  Those are four games against teams that look better than Richmond heading into 2011.  With little room for error, they can't go 0-4 against those teams and also suffer an expected loss to a team like Maine or UMass.  Despite the return of eight players on offense, I think the defense loses too much to allow the Spiders to improve on their 2010 record of 6-5.

Summary
Discounting the impact of freshmen players may have, it could be a frustrating season for Richmond.  If Aaron Corp stays healthy then he could be the driving force behind a return to the playoffs for the Spiders.  But does the defense lose too much for Richmond to remain competitive?  At best this team goes 7-4, which in the CAA is good enough for the playoffs, but it's hard to pick them to do better with what they lose on defense.

The Mayhem Era

Let me take you back to April 2009.  The Buffalo Bills had the eleventh overall pick in the NFL draft.  Rumors on message boards indicated that the team would take Aaron Maybin of Penn State with that selection.  Despite praying and hoping against all hope, the Bills did indeed take him.  I immediately texted my friend, "F--- Aaron Maybin."  I knew it was a wasted pick.

Brian Orakpo, Clay Matthews and Brandon Pettigrew were among players still available when the Bills took Maybin.  But Dick Jauron and Company were enamored by Maybin's speed...which was his only weapon to rush the passer in college.  He was a light defensive end at Penn State, weighing only 230 pounds.  He also only produced sacks against lesser competition, completely disappearing against teams like OSU and USC.  I am not a professional scout for an NFL team, but even I know this is an enormous red flag.

So we Bills fans were stuck with Aaron "Mayhem" Maybin.  Before recording a sack in the NFL, which he failed to do in two seasons, he hired a rapper to create a song about how awesome he is at sacking the quarterback.  He missed 24 practices in August's training camp his rookie year, and got to play in one preseason game.  Still, he suited up for all 16 games and had a handful of tackles without a sack.

In 2010 we brought in Chan Gailey as head coach, and he implemented a 3-4 defense.  Maybin was moved to OLB specifically to rush the passer.  His performance was so bad, however, that he was dropped down the depth chart behind a sixth-round pick (Arthur Moats) and an undrafted free agent (Antonio Coleman).  He played in 2/3 of the 2010 season.  None of this was lost on Yahoo Sports, who named him the worst player in the NFL that season.


A sixth-round pick of the 2010 draft had more sacks in one season than the eleventh overall pick of the 2009 draft had in two.

Fast forward to today, when the Bills officially released him.  This article from WGR550.com has a more detailed timeframe of Maybin's two years associated with the Buffalo Bills.  I'm not angry at Maybin for not working out.  It's not up to me to judge players who are better at their profession than I would be in their profession.

However, the whole Maybin saga encapsulates how frustrating it is to be a Bills fan.  We draft a kid with one good season who accumulated sacks only against the weaker competition faced in college; even that came only after the man in front of him on the depth chart was injured.  There were more talented, more accomplished players on the board behind him.  He missed two dozen training camp practices his rookie year because he was selfish and not interested in being the best player he could have been.  And two years later, we release him. 

I guess the good news is that the current Bills administration of Buddy Nix and Gailey are taking steps to improve the roster.  They're bringing in players to run the schemes they want to play.  When the 3-4 wasn't working last year because they didn't have the personnel, they switched to a 3-4/4-3 hybrid.  They've shown they're adaptable. 

But two years of Nix and Gailey at the helm won't magically change what's happened since 2000.  I'll leave you with the team's first round picks of the last several NFL drafts.  I will now go cry in my beer.

2010 - CJ Spiller
2009 - Aaron Maybin
2008 - Leodis McKelvin
2007 - Marshawn Lynch
2006 - Donte Whitner
2006 - John McCargo
2005 - None since we traded up for our second 2004 first round pick
2004 - Lee Evans
2004 - JP Losman
2003 - Willis McGahee
2002 - Mike Williams
2001 - Nate Clements

Sunday, August 14, 2011

James Madison Football Preview

When I was a student at Old Dominion 15 years ago, the composition of the Colonial Athletic Association was noticably different.  The teams in the league were ODU, W&M, George Mason, VCU, UNCW, JMU, East Carolina, Richmond and American (?).  At the turn of the century, ECU left for C-USA, Richmond went to the A-10 and American decided to take a step down to the Patriot League.  While ODU/VCU may be considered the biggest CAA rivalry now, as a student I hated James Madison more than anyone. 

My sister attended ODU a couple years before I did and she talked way more about disliking the Dukes more than anyone else.  In the early 90's the basketball team was relevant under the guidance of Lefty Drisell and even in the late '90's, I can remember a close contest decided late by Cal Bowdler's free throws.  So the basketball rivalry was one of two reasons I couldn't stand James Madison.

The other reason for disdain for the Dukes is simple jealousy that they had football.  I followed ODU basketball because both the men's and women's teams were the flagships of the athletic department.  But football has been my passion for as long as Jim Kelly was quarterbacking the Bills in the late 80's.  I would videotape Bills games and watch them over and over, learning (in a very amateurish manner) the ins and outs of football.  All my friends from high school went to UVa, Virginia Tech or James Madison.  And they all had their own football teams!  I had a great women's basketball team and a men's team that was on the decline.  Meanwhile, the Dukes were part of a football conference with other CAA teams like W&M and Richmond.

I provide this information so the reader understands how exciting the October 29 matchup between the football Dukes and Monarchs is for me.  Yes basketball is fun but it was never my passion like football has been.  The Athletics Department also understands the importance of the game, bringing back the underrated Oyster Bowl from the grave.  All-time greats like Roger Staubach and Bruce Smith participated in the event, so its history is more than a little rich.  Last year's game against William and Mary was fun and entertaining, but I expect the atmosphere between ODU and JMU to surpass that contest.

Old Dominion takes on long-time CAA rival James Madison on October 29.

Football History
James Madison University was founded in 1902 and the school has had a football program only since 1972.  Despite such a short existence they've accumulated a phenomenal record of 247-187-4.  They have claimed at least a share in four conference champioships and won the 2004 FCS national title behind standout Curtis Keaton.  The Dukes have been coached by Mickey Matthews the last twelve seasons, and he enters the 2011 season with a record of 88-56 during his tenure with the program. 

Special attention should be given to the expansion project of their home field, Bridgeforth Stadium.  Before recent expansion the stadium seated upwards of 20K.  You can view the amazing transformation that has taken place by visiting the dedicated thread at the CAAZone. 

Bridgeforth Stadium as of early August 2011.  This venue may be the best in the CAA.

2010 Highlights
It's difficult to find one word to describe the 2010 season.  In the second week of the season they upset the Virginia Tech Hokies, a BCS team that would go on to win the 2010 ACC title.  After starting the season 3-0, the Dukes would end up with a record of only 6-5.  They lost four of their last five games against ranked FCS opponents by seven points or less.  The defense was ferocious, allowing a combined 102 points in the first three quarters of their eleven games.  However, the offense failed to produce sufficient points and/or milk the clock with their leads, and the worn-down defense gave up 60 points in four quarters (including three in overtime). 

James Madison defeated eventual-ACC champion Virginia Tech on the road in 2010.
There was only one All-CAA First Teamer on James Madison, defensive tackle Ronnel Brown.  DR Bryant and Lamar Middleton tied for the team lead in sacks with 2.5 each while Stephon Robertson led the team with 8.5 TFL.  Second Team running back Jamal Sullivan led the Dukes with more than 700 rushing yards, while Kerby Long led the team with 16 catches and 283 receiving yards.  This was not a team that moved the ball through the air.  This team had the talent to beat Virginia Tech on the road, but the offense held them back from reaching its full potential. 

History with Old Dominion
This will be the first meeting between James Madison and Old Dominion on the football field.  As mentioned above, this initial matchup will be the rebirth of the Oyster Bowl. 

Bringing back the Oyster Bowl is the complete (re)birth of the cool.
2011 Outlook
I expect the James Madison Dukes to win at least eight games during the regular season, and then have a successful postseason in the playoffs.  The defense returns nine players from an exceptional 2010 unit.  I cannot stress enough how tough this defense was last year, but were let down by their offense.  I saw with my own eyes how they were physically beating down UMass, only the offense couldn't stay on the field and a run-down defense gave up late touchdowns in an eventual loss.

With a defense expected to shine, the offense will determine how far the program will go in 2011.  Gone is starting QB Drew Dudzik, who was also the team's third leading rusher.  The Dukes' other top-two rushers are lost to graduation.  Five of the team's leaders in receptions return, but fans are high on true freshman Amir Waller.  Most importantly, four offensive lineman who started last year are returning in 2011; the unit is led by 2011 preseason All-CAA OL Roane Babington.  This run-focused offense will rely on the lineman to open up holes for new running backs.

It was announced during the offseason that Matthews will be taking over the play-calling duties in 2011.  Will this lead to more points?  I think it does, if only because the law of averages will dictate that the team will win more games decided by seven points or less.


Any analysis of JMU allows the opportunity to announce, Don't Cross the Moats!

I've already called this Dukes team the national title contender that is getting minimal attention.  If the Dukes could have gotten one more touchdown against either Richmond (13-10 OT loss) or W&M (30-24 loss), then the seven wins would've been enough to get into the playoffs last year.  Surely the team will get one more touchdown at a crucial juncture next season.

Summary
It's nice to have James Madison relevant in my life again.  On the one hand their basketball program has fallen off while ours has gone on to new heights.  Conversely the Dukes have had football for decades and we're just getting started.  It will be tough for Thomas DeMarco to score many points against this Dukes' defense.  As tough as the Dukes' defense will be, the offense may take a step back without its starting QB or RB from last season.  But since this game is more than ten weeks away, it's too soon to make a prediction. 

Friday, August 12, 2011

Villanova Football Preview

Any reference to Old Dominion University and Villanova University begins and ends with two words:  PETEY SESSOMS!!!


Kerry Kittles and Villanova lost to Petey Sessoms and Old Dominion University in the 1995 NCAA Tournament.  This was the highlight of the Jeff Capel era, which is sad since it was his first year as head coach.

Football History
Villanova University was founded in 1842 and their football program began in 1892.  A member of D1-AA/FCS football since 1987, the Wildcats have accumulated a record of 573-447-39 during the 120 years-ish of existence.  There was a period of 1981-1984 where the administration cancelled the program, but it was brought back for the 1985 season.  The head coach of that season, Andy Talley, has remained at the helm ever since.

Since joining D1-AA Villanova has had at least a share in five conference championships.  They won the FCS national title in 2009 and made the semifinals last year, losing to eventual champion Eastern Washington.  A full-time member of the Big East, the CAA Football member plays its home games in the aptly-named Villanova Stadium.  There have been nine Wildcats to make the NFL since Villanova was part of the Yankee Conference, including Brian Westbrook and more recently, Ben Ijalana.

2010 Highlights
The Wildcats had a bit of a bumpy 2010 regular season.  They entered the season finale 6-4, needing a win at #1 Delaware to make the FCS playoffs.  With that mission accomplished in OT, their talent was too much for Stephen F. Austin and Appalachian State on the road.  All-Everything RB/WR/QB/Chicago Cub Matt Szczur missed a significant portion of the season with injuries, but kicked it into high gear against SFA and Appy State.  The team's third consecutive road playoff game was too much, and the team fell at Eastern Washington 41-31.

There were three Wildcats on the 2010 All-CAA First Team offensive and two on the defensive team.  Quarterback Chris Whitney was one of three players on the Second Team.  All four regular season losses were by seven points or less, including losses to FBS' Temple and FCS-ranked William & Mary and New Hampshire.  You've got to think that had Matt Szczur played a full season like he had the previous two seasons, the Wildcats wouldn't won more games and may have had at least one home playoff game.


Had Matt Szczur played in more than five regular season games, Villanova may have had an even better record.

History with Old Dominion
The October 22 contest in Philadelphia will be the first football meeting between Villanova and Old Dominion.

2011 Outlook
At this point I have insufficient data to establish expectations on what the Wildcats' 2011 record will be.  They lose a four-year starting QB to graduation; his expected replacement is either a redshirt freshman or one of two true freshmen.  The top four rushing leaders are all lost to graduation.  The offensive line loses NFL prospect Ben Ijalana and two-time All-CAA Brant Clouser.  2011 preseason All-CAA Norman White returns to lead a stable wide receiver corps.

The Wildcats have employed a 3-3-5 defense in the past; whether they continue with that in 2011 is to be determined.  The defensive line should be in good shape behind sophomore Antoine Lewis, but the team must replace all three starting linebackers from 2010's squad.  The defense also returns both starting CB's from last year.

What does it all mean?  We know from the above two paragraphs that the returning team is young at several positions, most notably QB and linebackers.  But we also know that the team has picked up its recruiting in recent years, so although the talent may be inexperienced, it does indeed exist.  There have been open communications between Villanova and the Big East to get the team to join the football conference. 

Recently the overall vote has been delayed, but the interest is there on both sides.  The major hangup seems to be the stadium issue, as Villanova Stadium seats only 12K with minimal expansion options.  The Wildcats will play their final home game at PPL Park, a larger venue that still has not impressed other Big East football members.  This is a topic for full discussion in another post, but the key is that Villanova has probably sold its recruits on eventually playing in a BCS conference before they graduate. 

Villanova loses much on both offense and defense, but the experienced players they do return should be able to guide the younger talent to win its share of games.  I expect a 6-5 overall record.  The 2012 team will be a team that challenges for a national title, but I think there will be too many growing pains in 2011 to get them back to the playoffs.  The team is two years removed from a national title, so winning is part of their pedigree.  It's too soon to determine how many wins that pedigree attains in 2011.


Coach Andy Talley has accomplished much in 26 years as HC at Villanova.

Summary
In Coach Talley's 26 seasons as its head coach, Villanova has had a winning record in 20 of them.  This is not an accident - the man recruits talent and coaches them up to national-title abilities.  But with only nine starters returning in 2011, will this be the 21st winning season?  It's hard to discount that trend of success so they should win at least six games.  It says here that they are going to take a step back this season, followed by three steps forward in 2012.  Will this translate into a team Old Dominion can defeat in 2011?  It's too soon to tell, but the opportunity is there.  And the 1995 Wildcats know what happened when Old Dominion is given an opportunity in to win its share of games.